Choosing the right rental car company can make or break your trip.This choice can either elevate your journey or throw a wrench into your well-laid plans. Hidden fees, unreliable vehicles, and subpar customer service can quickly turn your adventure into a nightmare.
To help you navigate this terrain, we’ve scoured real customer reviews and comparison portals, compiling an all-you-need-to-know, no-nonsense guide.
Thrifty Car Rental: Affordable but at What Cost?
Part of the Hertz family since 1958, Thrifty aims to offer budget-friendly rentals. However, aggressive upselling tactics and customer service issues have marred their reputation.
Renters have expressed dissatisfaction with the sales pressure at the counter and billing disputes. One traveler shared:

While the allure of lower rates is understandable, it’s essential to be vigilant about additional charges and to ensure that the final agreement aligns with your expectations.
- Cost-Effective Options: Targets budget-conscious travelers with competitive rates. โConsumer Affairs
- High Insurance Pressure: Reports of aggressive tactics to sell insurance add-ons. โ
- Inconsistent Customer Service: Varied experiences with staff professionalism and assistance.
Advantage Rent A Car: A Roll of the Dice
Advantage has been in the car rental business since 1963, but longevity doesn’t always equate to reliability. Travelers have reported issues with vehicle availability and unexpected charges. Their Review Score ranges from 1.6 Stars on Yelp to 3.6 Stars on Google.

Instances of overbooking and long wait times have been noted. A frustrated renter recounted, “They will take your money without giving an explanation… The car we got was old, dingy, and sordid.”
Such experiences highlight the importance of reading reviews and understanding company policies before booking.โ
- Competitive Pricing: Offers lower rental rates compared to some major competitors. โ
- Aggressive Upselling: Customers have reported pressure to purchase additional services.
Fox Rent A Car: Budget-Friendly Options with Trade-Offs
Fox Rent A Car is recognized for its affordability, attracting budget-conscious travelers. It’s getting mixed reviews, with one user reporting on Trustpilot:
Kind of a mixed bag. Upon arriving at the office another client and I were told that there were no cars available, despite both of our confirmed reservations. The manager said that he was only honoring pre-paid reservations. The other gent ended up securing a car after he told them that a local friend had called to make the reso. I think I looked so deflated and defeated that they decided they had a car for me after all.
meaning while lots of people have reported good experiences with Fox, some frequent complaints are about hidden fees/unexpected costs. Users have reported long wait times during pick-up and drop-off, suggesting that while the rates are competitive, the service experience may involve delays.
- Affordable Rates: Known for budget-friendly pricing options.
- Vehicle Maintenance Issues: Some customers report concerns about car conditions. โ
- Long Wait Times: Renters have experienced delays during pick-up and drop-off.
Sixt Rent A Car: European Flair with a Modern Twist
Originating in Germany in 1912, Sixt has expanded its footprint, offering a fleet that includes premium brands like BMW, Mercedes-Benz, and Audi. Their competitive pricing allows renters to experience luxury without an exorbitant price tag.

Travelers have praised Sixt for their high-end vehicle options and modern approach to car rentals. One renter mentioned, “Rented a BMW from Sixt. Best car rental experience I’ve had.”
However, experiences can vary by location, and some customers have reported issues with customer service and unexpected charges. It’s advisable to review terms thoroughly and document the vehicle’s condition upon pickup.โ
- Premium Vehicle Selection: Provides luxury brands like BMW and Mercedes-Benz. โ
- 24/7 Customer Support: Offers round-the-clock assistance for renters. โ
- Price Fluctuations: Rental rates can vary significantly based on location and demand.
Enterprise Rent-A-Car: The Neighborhood Ally
Since its inception in 1957, Enterprise has built a reputation for exceptional customer service and community presence. Their unique offering of picking up customers directly speaks to their commitment to convenience. With numerous neighborhood locations, Enterprise makes renting accessible and straightforward.
Customers frequently highlight the professionalism of Enterprise staff and the cleanliness of their vehicles. A satisfied customer noted,
“The customer service at Enterprise Rent-A-Car… has exemplary service. The whole team and management… was willing to go over and beyond what was required.”

However, some renters have encountered challenges, particularly with vehicle availability during peak seasons. Planning ahead and confirming reservations can help ensure a seamless experience.
- Extensive Network: Over 8,000 global locations, including neighborhood branches. โConsumer Affairs
- Diverse Fleet: Offers a wide range of vehicles from economy cars to exotic options.
National Car Rental: The Gold Standard
Founded in 1947, National Car Rental has consistently prioritized customer convenience. Their Emerald Club loyalty program allows members to bypass the counter and select their preferred vehicle directly from the lot. This streamlined process has earned National a loyal following.
One happy customer left this Google Review:

However, it’s worth noting that no company is without its hiccups. Some customers have reported issues with roadside assistance and unexpected charges. Yet, National’s proactive approach to addressing concerns often mitigates potential dissatisfaction.โConsumer Affairs
Understanding Rental Car Loyalty Programs
Let’s rev up our engines and dive into loyalty programs โ your ticket to the fast lane of car rental perks!
- Enterprise Plus leads the pack, offering one point per dollar spent on base rental fees. Rack up 600 points for a free day, with points lasting a whopping three years. It’s like having a pit crew that doesn’t rush you!
- Avis Preferred follows close behind, matching the one point per dollar on rentals and adding two points per dollar on accessories. A free rental day requires 700 points, but watch out โ redemption can be trickier than a hairpin turn. Points vanish after 12 months of inactivity, so keep those wheels spinning!
- Hertz Gold Plus Rewards brings up the rear. While they match the one point per dollar, they’re stingier at payout. You’ll need at least 950 points for one free day โ talk about a long haul! Plus, those points disappear faster than tire smoke, lasting only a year without activity.
These programs are more than just free rentals โ they’re about building a long-term relationship, like you have with your favorite ride. Whether you prefer Enterprise’s laid-back approach, Avis’s detailed strategy, or Hertz’s flexibility, there’s a program to suit every driver’s style. Now floor it and start earning those points!
Getting the Best Deal on Car Rentals
Time to tune up your rental skills and race ahead of those sneaky fees! First, watch out for hidden charges โ they’re like unexpected potholes that can ruin your trip. Scrutinize the fine print and confirm what’s included in your quote.
Compare rates like you’re sizing up the competition at a drag race. Use online tools to get a panoramic view of your options, looking past the initial “low-rent” appeal to grasp the full cost after taxes and fees.
Discounts and loyalty programs are your nitrous boost to protect your wallet. Programs like Enterprise Plus and National’s Emerald Club can lead to free days and quick upgrades. Don’t forget to hunt for promo codes โ it’s like finding extra horsepower with a few clicks!
When checking out your ride, inspect it like you’re at a car show. Document any damage before you peel out to avoid unexpected charges when you return.
With these tips in your toolbox, you’re ready to hit the rental circuit and come out ahead. Keep those wheels spinning and the savings rolling in!
The Impact of Location and Fleet Size
Location and fleet size can make or break your rental experience โ it’s the difference between revving up quickly or stalling at the starting line. Let’s see how the big players stack up:
- Enterprise dominates with 2.1 million cars and over 9,500 locations across nearly 100 countries. It’s like having an auto show on speed dial! This massive fleet means options galore, from zippy compacts to roaring SUVs.
- Avis impresses with service in 165 countries and 5,500 locations. They’re the go-to for globe-trotting gearheads, ensuring you’ll find a ride whether you’re craving Arctic adventures or tropical cruises.
- Hertz balances the field with 8,500 locations across 146 countries โ more global reach than Enterprise. While they might not have the biggest fleet, they’ve got you covered from Siberian snowstorms to Australian outback adventures.
More cars and locations mean better convenience and satisfaction. Enterprise often tops the charts thanks to its extensive fleet and widespread presence. Avis shines as a world traveler’s best friend, while Hertz finds its sweet spot balancing both aspects.
When booking, think beyond just grabbing any old set of wheels. Consider the comfort of a comprehensive fleet and nearby locations. Whether you’re Team Enterprise, Avis, or Hertz, choose the rental that’ll fuel your driving dreams and keep you in the fast lane of satisfaction!
Buckle up and choose wisely! The right rental company can turbocharge your travels, whether you’re conquering city streets or tearing up the open road. Pick a partner that offers crystal-clear pricing, killer value, and smooth convenience โ it’s your ticket to the ultimate joyride!
